Online reviews shape what we buy, where we eat, and which brands we trust. But what about the customers who never leave one? Discover why extreme experiences dominate online ratings, how psychology influences what people choose to share, and what businesses might be missing about their most ordinary customers.


It’s long been accepted in marketing that good online reviews are enormously valuable. They build trust, influence buying decisions, and help businesses attract customers. They also influence visibility, with Google, hotel booking platforms, and online marketplaces using ratings and reviews in various ways to rank and recommend businesses. Reviews don’t just help people decide where to go; they can influence which businesses people see in the first place.

But how much can we actually trust online reviews as a reflection of customer experiences? We tend to treat them as honest accounts of what people think and feel, yet there’s an important question we rarely ask: what makes someone decide to write a review in the first place?

Think about the last time you left one. Was it because everything worked more or less as expected? Or was it because something was particularly good, or perhaps particularly bad? Most of us are probably more inclined to share the experiences that stand out, whether that’s an exceptional restaurant meal, a disappointing hotel, or a surprisingly good product.

But what about everything in between? The perfectly acceptable meals, the products that do their job, and the customer service that was neither particularly good nor bad? These experiences make up a large part of everyday consumer life, yet they’re often missing from online reviews. To understand why, we need to look at the psychology behind what people choose to share, and what that means for businesses relying on reviews to understand their customers.

Most customers aren’t having five-star experiences

If you’ve spent time looking through customer reviews, you’ve probably noticed something odd. There tend to be a lot of five-star reviews, a fair number of one-star reviews, and far fewer in the middle. Researchers call this a J-shaped distribution, and it’s a well-known pattern in consumer research.

In one study, researchers Nan Hu, Paul Pavlou, and Jie Zhang examined Amazon reviews and found that ratings were heavily weighted toward the extremes, especially the positive end. But when people were asked to review products rather than choosing for themselves whether to leave a review, the ratings became much more balanced. The moderate opinions had been there all along. People simply hadn’t felt much need to share them.

A larger study by Schoenmueller, Netzer, and Stahl, covering more than 280 million reviews across 25 platforms, found similar patterns. People with strong opinions were more likely to leave reviews, while those with moderate experiences were less likely to take part.

This challenges a common belief about online reviews: that they give us a fair picture of customer satisfaction. In reality, we’re not just seeing how satisfied people are. We’re also seeing how motivated they are to share their opinions.

When everything goes as expected, there’s not much to talk about

There’s a fairly simple reason why ordinary experiences rarely inspire reviews, and it has a lot to do with how we respond to our expectations.

If you order a coffee, you expect it to be warm, taste good, and arrive without too much trouble. When that’s exactly what happens, there’s little reason to think much more about it. But imagine the coffee is exceptionally good, or that it arrives cold after twenty minutes and the barista gets your order wrong. Suddenly, there’s something worth remembering.

This connects to a concept in consumer psychology called expectation disconfirmation. In simple terms, how satisfied we feel depends partly on the gap between what we expect and what we get. When something exceeds our expectations, we notice. When it falls short, we notice that too. But when it simply meets them, there’s much less to think about.

Neuroscience offers an interesting parallel. Research into reward prediction errors has shown that certain dopamine neurons respond more strongly when outcomes differ from what was expected. While this doesn’t directly explain why someone writes a review, the basic idea is relevant: our brains pay more attention to things that surprise us.

Emotion adds another layer. Research by Jonah Berger and Katherine Milkman found that online content linked to strong, activating emotions was more likely to be shared than content linked to calmer emotions. Later studies have questioned parts of this explanation, but the difference between how strongly we feel and whether those feelings are positive or negative remains useful.

A surprisingly good experience can create excitement or delight, while a poor one might cause frustration or anger. Both give people a reason to talk about what happened, while an ordinary experience rarely creates the same urge.

We remember the highlights, not the whole experience

There’s another problem with using reviews to understand customer experiences. People aren’t always reviewing what happened, but rather what they remember of it, and memory doesn’t keep a perfect record.

Research linked to Daniel Kahneman and Barbara Fredrickson has shown that our memories of an experience can be shaped by its most intense moment and how it ended. This is known as the peak-end rule, and it helps explain why certain moments can shape how we remember an entire experience.

Think about a holiday. You might spend a week having a pleasant time, but when you look back, a few moments probably stand out. Perhaps it was an incredible dinner, a beautiful place you didn’t expect to find, or the awful experience of missing your flight home. Those moments become the story of the holiday, even though they were only a small part of the trip.

Customer experiences can work in much the same way. A very helpful employee might turn an ordinary shopping trip into something memorable, while a frustrating checkout can overshadow everything that went well before it.

Experiences with strong emotional moments give customers something clear to write about. Ordinary experiences leave less behind, and as time passes, they can become even harder to recall. That doesn’t mean customers felt nothing at the time. They might have enjoyed parts of the experience or noticed small problems, but those moments don’t always stay with them long enough to become part of a review.

Writing a review needs to feel worthwhile

There’s also a simpler reason why people don’t review ordinary experiences: writing a review takes effort, and people generally need a reason to make that effort.

Research into word of mouth has found several reasons why people share their experiences. Some want to help others make better choices, some want to reward a business for great service, and others want to express frustration or warn people about a bad experience.

Think about how those reasons apply to an ordinary experience. If a product was excellent, recommending it feels useful, and if it was terrible, warning others feels worthwhile. But if it was just fine, there’s no strong reason to do either.

The choice to leave a review isn’t just about satisfaction. It’s also about whether sharing an opinion feels worth the time and effort. For customers in the middle, it often doesn’t, which means their experiences go largely unheard.

Interestingly, the middle does speak when you ask

One of the strongest signs that moderate customers aren’t indifferent comes from research into reviews that businesses actively request. When companies ask customers for feedback, the results often become more balanced.

Research by Hülya Karaman found that asking for reviews led more customers with moderate experiences to take part. It also reduced some of the bias toward extreme ratings found in reviews that people chose to write on their own.

Another study by Brandes, Godes, and Mayzlin looked at when to ask for reviews on a European travel platform. In an experiment involving around 190,000 bookings, they found that asking customers for feedback sooner led to more reviews and a smaller share of extreme ratings.

This suggests that the missing middle isn’t simply a case of customers having nothing to say. Sometimes, they just need to be asked before the experience fades from memory.

For brands, that’s an important point. A customer who doesn’t leave a review isn’t necessarily happy, unhappy, or indifferent. They may simply be someone who never had a strong enough reason to share their opinion.

What brands might be missing

For marketers and customer experience teams, I think the most interesting point is that we’re often measuring the experiences people want to tell us about, rather than the experiences most people are actually having.

Imagine a company with thousands of positive reviews and a high average rating. That’s clearly encouraging, but what about all the customers who never left a review? Were they just as happy? Did they run into small problems that weren’t worth complaining about? Could some of them be quietly thinking about trying a competitor?

We don’t really know, and that’s where relying too much on reviews becomes a problem. A customer doesn’t have to be angry to stop buying from you, just as they don’t have to be delighted to stay loyal. Ordinary experiences can still affect future choices, especially when small problems build up over time.

This is why brands should be interested in understanding the middle, rather than simply trying to collect more five-star reviews. A high rating is useful, but knowing what happened to the customers who never shared their opinions could be just as valuable.

Can neuromarketing help us better understand online reviews?

If online reviews are shaped by expectations, emotions, and memory, there’s an interesting opportunity to investigate what happens before someone decides to write one, and what happens when someone else reads it.

Most research into online reviews looks at the ratings and comments people leave behind. But those tell us relatively little about the experience that led to the review, or how people actually respond to the reviews they encounter. This is where neuromarketing methods could add another perspective.

For example, researchers could use eye tracking to investigate how consumers read reviews. Do they focus mainly on star ratings, or do they spend more time reading detailed accounts of other people’s experiences? Are negative reviews more likely to attract attention, and do people pay more attention to reviews that differ from the overall rating?

Eye tracking research has already explored how consumers engage with online reviews, including which information attracts attention and how people evaluate different review elements. Combined with surveys and behavioral measures, these methods can help us better understand how reviews influence buying decisions.

There’s also an interesting opportunity to study the people writing reviews. By measuring emotional responses during an experience and comparing them with the reviews participants later choose to write, researchers could investigate whether the strongest emotional moments are also the ones most likely to be mentioned. They could also examine whether people who show relatively little emotional response are less likely to leave a review at all.

These are research questions rather than established findings, but they could help us understand some of the psychological processes behind the silent middle.

Neuromarketing won’t tell us whether a review is honest or whether a customer is going to write one. But by combining measures of attention, emotional arousal, and behavior with traditional feedback, researchers could gain a clearer picture of how experiences become reviews, and how those reviews go on to influence other consumers.

The most interesting customers might be the ones who say nothing

There’s a tendency in marketing to focus on the extremes. We celebrate the customers who love us, look into the ones who complain, and spend a lot of time trying to understand what separates the two. That makes sense because strong reactions are easy to spot and often give us something to act on, but it also means we risk missing a large part of the customer experience.

The customers who think we’re just OK aren’t necessarily unhappy, but they’re not necessarily loyal either. They may have experienced a dozen small pleasures and frustrations that never added up to anything worth writing about. And because they don’t complain, recommend, or leave reviews, it’s easy to assume there’s nothing interesting to learn from them.

The research suggests otherwise. Reviews can tell us a great deal about what people felt strongly enough to talk about, but they don’t always tell us what most people experienced. For brands that want to understand their customers rather than simply collect ratings, that’s an important difference.

Perhaps the next useful customer insight won’t come from another five-star review or an angry complaint, but from taking a closer look at the experiences that customers thought were just fine.

Written by

Morten Pedersen

I’m Morten (Morty to everyone, really), content manager at iMotions in Copenhagen, where I write about why people look, frown and sweat at things. I also look after Neuromarketing.com, where the same questions get a longer airing.

More from Morten Pedersen →